In "The Ones Who Walk Away from Omelas", author Ursula Le Guin writes of a beautiful city where the people enjoy life at the expense of one child who has only known misery. Through symbolism, setting, and situational irony Le Guin examines the power individuals who live without morals.
Le Guin uses the child as a symbol of the oppressive mentality of those who let one individual live under extremely poor conditions so that everyone else can live happily. The child represents how even though the community of Omelas is described as, "mature, intelligent, passionate adults whose lives were not wretched", there is always a lingering oppression that everyone is aware of. The child proves how the people of Omelas have the power to subject an individual to extreme misery, and because the lack of morals prevents anyone from stopping it, the citizens continue living happily despite the treatment of the oppressed. Le Guin also uses setting to contrast the lives of the people in Omelas and the child. For example, Omelas is described as, "like a city in a fairy tale" and the setting of the child is described as a, "foul-smelling" basement room with a locked door and no windows. The contrast of lifestyles demonstrates how the people are superior to the child because they are able to keep the child locked away and unseen while they are free within their seemingly beautiful city. Le Guin employs setting to prove how because the people of Omelas have no morals or sympathy for the child, they exert their power to live a luxurious life while the child remains trapped and isolated from society. Finally, Le Guin uses situational irony of how the people respond to the child against what readers expect. By setting up Omelas to be a beautiful city with happy people, readers expect the people to have a negative reaction towards the cruel treatment of the child. However, situational irony is created because of how the majority of citizens just accept the child's oppression as a reality. This ultimately proves that their lack of morals gives most of the citizens the power to basically ignore how the child is being treated. Overall, through the use of symbolism, setting, and dramatic irony Le Guin proves how individuals with no morals easily exert their power over others.
Tuesday, September 30, 2014
Monday, September 29, 2014
"Hills Like White Elephants" -Ernest Hemingway
In "Hills Like White Elephants", author Ernest Hemingway writes about a couple struggling while trying to make a decision together. Through the use of symbolism and an apathetic tone, Hemingway characterizes the relationship between the characters as dysfunctional with a lack of clear communication.
Hemingway uses symbolism to represent the way the characters are avoiding the problem they have instead of talking through it. For example, the man refers to the girl as, "Jig" in the middle of the story. Through calling her "Jig", symbolism is established because it demonstrates how the characters are dancing around their conflict instead of tackling it head on. Hemingway then uses this symbolism to prove how their relationship is dysfunctional because the characters are unable to simply pinpoint their problem and discuss it as a couple to find a solution, leaving them to skirt around the decision and never really resolve it. Hemingway also uses an apathetic tone. For example the man says, "I wouldn't have you do it if you didn't want to. But I know it's perfectly simple". The man and the girl then continue to discuss this way going back and forth. The lack of emotion and feeling behind the words during their conversation demonstrates how neither the man nor the girl have strong feelings about what they are trying to figure out together. Hemingway uses their indifference in his apathetic tone to prove how the characters do not have a clear line of communication where they are expressing how they actually feel towards the problem. This then represents how their relationship is characterized as dysfunctional because the communication is not representing how they truly feel. Ultimately, Hemingway uses symbolism and an apathetic tone to prove how without clear communication, the relationship between the characters becomes dysfunctional.
Hemingway uses symbolism to represent the way the characters are avoiding the problem they have instead of talking through it. For example, the man refers to the girl as, "Jig" in the middle of the story. Through calling her "Jig", symbolism is established because it demonstrates how the characters are dancing around their conflict instead of tackling it head on. Hemingway then uses this symbolism to prove how their relationship is dysfunctional because the characters are unable to simply pinpoint their problem and discuss it as a couple to find a solution, leaving them to skirt around the decision and never really resolve it. Hemingway also uses an apathetic tone. For example the man says, "I wouldn't have you do it if you didn't want to. But I know it's perfectly simple". The man and the girl then continue to discuss this way going back and forth. The lack of emotion and feeling behind the words during their conversation demonstrates how neither the man nor the girl have strong feelings about what they are trying to figure out together. Hemingway uses their indifference in his apathetic tone to prove how the characters do not have a clear line of communication where they are expressing how they actually feel towards the problem. This then represents how their relationship is characterized as dysfunctional because the communication is not representing how they truly feel. Ultimately, Hemingway uses symbolism and an apathetic tone to prove how without clear communication, the relationship between the characters becomes dysfunctional.
Tuesday, September 23, 2014
"I Stand Here Ironing" -Tillie Olsen
In "I Stand Here Ironing", author Tillie Olsen writes of a woman reflecting on the effects on her first daughter growing up with a young, working, and single mother. Through a first person point of view, syntax, and an exhausted tone, Olsen examines the complex way individuals are impacted by their parents.
Olsen employs a first person point of view of the narrator who recalls the way her first daughter was raised differently from her siblings. While talking about her first daughter, Emily, the narrator says, "She had to help be a mother, and house keeper, and shopper" (270). Through the narrator's recollection, it is revealed how Emily had to take on more responsibility than her siblings because she is the oldest. This responsibility thus impacted Emily by having to grow up more quickly than her siblings to help them while her mother worked to support their family. Olsen also uses syntax through the narrator describing her conditions as a new mother first, and then later explaining how Emily changed as she grew older. This choice of placement creates a cause and effect template for the readers, helping them to understand the narrator's actions, and how those actions changed the way Emily grew up. Finally, Olsen's use of an exhausted tone demonstrates the constant struggle the narrator went through trying to provide for her family and take care of her oldest daughter through a difficult time. The narrator writes, "that terrible balancing of hurts and needs I had to do...and did so badly, those earlier years" (269). By writing words with such negative connotations reflecting on the narrator's performance as a mother, it is proved that the narrator is disappointed in herself, and is tired of doing a poor job with her children. The narrator's sense of remorse also gives readers a sense of how her children, especially Emily, must have felt during those early years, and how they were inevitable impacted by their mother's struggles to support them. Ultimately, Olsen uses point of view, syntax, and an exhausted tone to prove that the way individuals grow up is inevitably correlated to the performance of the parents who raise them.
Olsen employs a first person point of view of the narrator who recalls the way her first daughter was raised differently from her siblings. While talking about her first daughter, Emily, the narrator says, "She had to help be a mother, and house keeper, and shopper" (270). Through the narrator's recollection, it is revealed how Emily had to take on more responsibility than her siblings because she is the oldest. This responsibility thus impacted Emily by having to grow up more quickly than her siblings to help them while her mother worked to support their family. Olsen also uses syntax through the narrator describing her conditions as a new mother first, and then later explaining how Emily changed as she grew older. This choice of placement creates a cause and effect template for the readers, helping them to understand the narrator's actions, and how those actions changed the way Emily grew up. Finally, Olsen's use of an exhausted tone demonstrates the constant struggle the narrator went through trying to provide for her family and take care of her oldest daughter through a difficult time. The narrator writes, "that terrible balancing of hurts and needs I had to do...and did so badly, those earlier years" (269). By writing words with such negative connotations reflecting on the narrator's performance as a mother, it is proved that the narrator is disappointed in herself, and is tired of doing a poor job with her children. The narrator's sense of remorse also gives readers a sense of how her children, especially Emily, must have felt during those early years, and how they were inevitable impacted by their mother's struggles to support them. Ultimately, Olsen uses point of view, syntax, and an exhausted tone to prove that the way individuals grow up is inevitably correlated to the performance of the parents who raise them.
Monday, September 22, 2014
"Cathedral" -Raymond Carver
1. The narrator initially reveals himself to the reader by telling his wife's story, and the relationship she has with the blind man coming to visit. His initial tone seems negative, as if he is aggravated to be associated with the blind man and has to tell his story, even though he does not want to. In the beginning the narrator really does not reveal anything about himself, other than the fact that it is his wife's association with the blind man. While introducing the story to readers, the narrator leaves out details of his wife's first husband's name, referring to him only as, "the officer" (1080). He also leaves out the blind man's actual name. This indicates how even though these two people are crucial to his wife's life, he refuses to give their names to the reader, proving his negativity towards them.
2. The narrator sets up the reader for it to be an unpleasant visit. He does this by revealing to the refer the conversation he has with his wife prior towards Robert's arrival. This encounter sets a negative tone because the narrator and his wee are short with each other, as if they disagree on Robert staying with them. My response is different from the narrator's because the narrator is judging his every move and is unaware how to even talk to a blind man. Whereas my reaction was less biased because I was aware of the narrator's dislike for the blind man because of the way he set up his visit. Carver develops Robert's and the narrator's characters through highlighting their contrasts during the conversation. During the dinner, Robert tries to get to know the narrator through conversation, portraying him as making an effort to connect with one of his hosts. However, Carver then contrasts Robert's behavior to the narrator's because as the narrator answers he makes comments in his head that judge Robert, not being open minded.
3. Blindness is directly and indirectly a subject of 'Cathedral". To begin with, it is addressed directly when readers learn of Robert being physically blind. This is important to the story because it adds through Robert's character that even though one can physically not see things, it does not mean they are blind in the sense that they are not insightful or unaware of the other aspects of life. Robert's character demonstrates this because even though he is blind, he still takes the time to better himself and talks about how despite his blindness he is still able, "to learn something" (1086). This blindness adds complexity to the story by serving as a contrast to the narrator's indirect blindness. The narrator is indirectly blind by being extremely ignorant to the world around him. The narrator is blind in the sense that he makes judgements quickly about what he cannot completely understand, like when he first meets Robert and does not know how to talk to him because he is blind. This adds complexity to the story because it proves that blindness is not just physical, and many people in society are blind in the sense that they are ignorant to what they do not understand.
5. At the end, the narrator has an epiphany while drawing the cathedral with Robert. I think Carver withholds the information about what the narrator's specific epiphany is because it signals how the narrator has changed. Before, the readers were clued in to all if the narrator's thoughts and reactions to what has been going on, however the reader is left out of his epiphany. This shift signals how instead of the narrator being quick to judge and the reader immediately knowing his thoughts, he is actually thinking deeper and his epiphany is not revealed because the narrator has become more open minded. Other information withheld from the reader is the narrator's actual name as well. I think Carver does this to prove that many people are prejudiced to what they do not understand, like the way the narrator is prejudiced to Robert because of his blindness. By leaving out the narrator's name, Carver demonstrates how anyone could be prejudiced, not just one specific person.
6. The narrator and his wife do not have the typical relationship most married people do. Instead of a relationship based upon love, their relationship lacks communication and the only time they are spending together is spent by watching television, eating, and using drugs. I do not think Carver judges them because these things do not seem distinguished in their marriage. Carver makes it seem as though this is completely normal and routine for a married couple. I do judge them because I expect a married couple to behave differently. For example, I expect a married couple to be able to interact without the need for drugs and excess drinking. However, the narrator and his wife are the opposite of my expectation.
2. The narrator sets up the reader for it to be an unpleasant visit. He does this by revealing to the refer the conversation he has with his wife prior towards Robert's arrival. This encounter sets a negative tone because the narrator and his wee are short with each other, as if they disagree on Robert staying with them. My response is different from the narrator's because the narrator is judging his every move and is unaware how to even talk to a blind man. Whereas my reaction was less biased because I was aware of the narrator's dislike for the blind man because of the way he set up his visit. Carver develops Robert's and the narrator's characters through highlighting their contrasts during the conversation. During the dinner, Robert tries to get to know the narrator through conversation, portraying him as making an effort to connect with one of his hosts. However, Carver then contrasts Robert's behavior to the narrator's because as the narrator answers he makes comments in his head that judge Robert, not being open minded.
3. Blindness is directly and indirectly a subject of 'Cathedral". To begin with, it is addressed directly when readers learn of Robert being physically blind. This is important to the story because it adds through Robert's character that even though one can physically not see things, it does not mean they are blind in the sense that they are not insightful or unaware of the other aspects of life. Robert's character demonstrates this because even though he is blind, he still takes the time to better himself and talks about how despite his blindness he is still able, "to learn something" (1086). This blindness adds complexity to the story by serving as a contrast to the narrator's indirect blindness. The narrator is indirectly blind by being extremely ignorant to the world around him. The narrator is blind in the sense that he makes judgements quickly about what he cannot completely understand, like when he first meets Robert and does not know how to talk to him because he is blind. This adds complexity to the story because it proves that blindness is not just physical, and many people in society are blind in the sense that they are ignorant to what they do not understand.
5. At the end, the narrator has an epiphany while drawing the cathedral with Robert. I think Carver withholds the information about what the narrator's specific epiphany is because it signals how the narrator has changed. Before, the readers were clued in to all if the narrator's thoughts and reactions to what has been going on, however the reader is left out of his epiphany. This shift signals how instead of the narrator being quick to judge and the reader immediately knowing his thoughts, he is actually thinking deeper and his epiphany is not revealed because the narrator has become more open minded. Other information withheld from the reader is the narrator's actual name as well. I think Carver does this to prove that many people are prejudiced to what they do not understand, like the way the narrator is prejudiced to Robert because of his blindness. By leaving out the narrator's name, Carver demonstrates how anyone could be prejudiced, not just one specific person.
6. The narrator and his wife do not have the typical relationship most married people do. Instead of a relationship based upon love, their relationship lacks communication and the only time they are spending together is spent by watching television, eating, and using drugs. I do not think Carver judges them because these things do not seem distinguished in their marriage. Carver makes it seem as though this is completely normal and routine for a married couple. I do judge them because I expect a married couple to behave differently. For example, I expect a married couple to be able to interact without the need for drugs and excess drinking. However, the narrator and his wife are the opposite of my expectation.
Thursday, September 18, 2014
Characterization and "Where Are You Going, Where Have You Been?"
In "Where Are You Going, Where Have You Been?" Joyce Carol Oates tells the story of an entitled teenager who becomes unwillingly involved with a dangerous man. Through Connie's desperation for attention, Oates magnifies the danger of allowing one's self image to cloud their judgement.
Oates uses characterization to distinguish Connie as a teenager that only cares about her image and looks down on others. Connie often comments on her distaste for her older sister June, believing that she is better looking and that is all that matters. The contempt Connie holds for June because of appearance demonstrates Connie as a flat character, self-absorbed and unwilling to change. The standard Connie holds herself to draws the attention of Arnold who praises her beauty, gaining the intrigue of Connie. Connie begins to notice the suspicious characteristics of Arnold such as his age, and the suspicious way he talks as though he is pretending to be something he's not. This represents how Arnold is initially seen as not a typical teenager that could be a friend to Connie. However, Connie's hesitation to put an end to her interaction with Arnold exemplifies how even though she can recognize there is something not right, she continues because she enjoys the ego boost. Connie later being forced to leave with Arnold, unwillingly putting herself into a very dangerous situation, ultimately proves Oates's message that allowing the desire to have an elevated self-image overpower an individual's better judgement will inevitably lead to a potentially dangerous situation that could have been avoided.
Oates uses characterization to distinguish Connie as a teenager that only cares about her image and looks down on others. Connie often comments on her distaste for her older sister June, believing that she is better looking and that is all that matters. The contempt Connie holds for June because of appearance demonstrates Connie as a flat character, self-absorbed and unwilling to change. The standard Connie holds herself to draws the attention of Arnold who praises her beauty, gaining the intrigue of Connie. Connie begins to notice the suspicious characteristics of Arnold such as his age, and the suspicious way he talks as though he is pretending to be something he's not. This represents how Arnold is initially seen as not a typical teenager that could be a friend to Connie. However, Connie's hesitation to put an end to her interaction with Arnold exemplifies how even though she can recognize there is something not right, she continues because she enjoys the ego boost. Connie later being forced to leave with Arnold, unwillingly putting herself into a very dangerous situation, ultimately proves Oates's message that allowing the desire to have an elevated self-image overpower an individual's better judgement will inevitably lead to a potentially dangerous situation that could have been avoided.
Wednesday, September 17, 2014
Setting and "The Yellow Wallpaper"
In, "The Yellow Wallpaper", Charlotte Perkins Gilman tells the
story of a woman who struggles to conquer her depression while isolated in a
nursery. Through the narrator's loss of reality as her focus becomes solely the
yellow wallpaper; Gilman emphasizes the negative impact of a forced setting on
someone struggling to find his or her identity. At first, the narrator protests
being in the nursery saying to her husband, "do let us go downstairs"
(1069). The narrator has expressed her negativity towards the room, yet her
husband makes the decision of forcing her to stay in the room. His power
reflects the oppression of the narrator, beginning her mental deterioration. As
she spends more and more time with the yellow wallpaper, the narrator begins to
see figures she can relate to. She writes, "In the very bright spots she
keeps still, and in the very shady spots she just takes hold of the bars and
shakes them hard" (1075). Her isolation has separated her from people for
so long she begins to create them in her mind. She relates herself to the
figure because she stays quiet when being watched by her husband, but when she
is alone she makes her own decisions. The impact of the isolation has led her
to become overly obsessed with the wallpaper and desperate for human
interaction. Gilman's use of isolation ultimately proves how it negatively
impacted the narrator because her thoughts become increasingly irrational. By
being forced to stay in there, the narrator has taken the different aspects of
her own identity and twisted them in her mind to being associated with the
yellow wallpaper, and has only furthered the deterioration of her mental state
instead of improving it.
Monday, September 15, 2014
"The Yellow Wallpaper" -Charlotte Perkins Gilman
1. The narrator changes significantly as she
spends her three weeks in the nursery with the yellow wallpaper. As the
narrator becomes more and more obsessed with the wallpaper, her sanity seems to
decline. At first, the narrator focuses on her depression and believes, “that
congenial work, with excitement and change, would do me good” (1067). The
narrator starts off with her own ideas of how she can make herself better,
despite the opinions of her husband. However, as she continues to stay in this
house, she adopts a more domestic view and complies with her husband, staying
quiet and focusing on the wallpaper. The narrator’s changes are marked by her
reaction to the wallpaper because of the way she becomes obsessed and
possessive of it. She writes, “But I know she was studying that pattern, and I
am determined that nobody shall find it out but myself” (1074). This change
from the narrator originally focusing on healthy ways to make herself better
like writing has been replaced by an obsessive desire to focus on only the
wallpaper. The narrator believes she is feeling better, “because of the wall-paper” signaling her growing positivity to the
room she once detested (1074). I disagree with the narrator’s positivity
towards her change because of the wallpaper, because her fixation with the
wallpaper has driven her to the point where it is all she thinks about, taking
away from her mental sanity.
2. Despite the fact that the nursery is supposedly a place where
children could play and learn, the characteristics of the nursery seem as
though it served another function entirely. The narrator describes the room
with, “the barred windows, and then that gate at the head of the stairs”
(1068). These characteristics of the nursery make it seem as it functioned as
more of a jail cell rather than a place of fond memories for children. This
represents the development of the narrator because the narrator feels trapped
within her depression and actually begins to relate herself to the wallpaper of
the nursery. She writes, “the faint figure behind seemed to shake the pattern,
just as if she wanted to get out” (1072). As the narrator begins to see a
figure within the wallpaper, she relates to that figure. The way she sees the
figure as trapped in a representation of her feelings within her mind. The
nursery being described like a jail cell even more so accentuates the idea that
not only is the narrator trapped by her depression, but she is also trapped in
this room as she tries to deal with it, unable to escape from either.
4. The syntax used by the author to describe
the wallpaper mirrors the confusing pattern of the wallpaper and the author’s
aggravation in trying to figure it out. She writes, “But on the other hand,
they connect diagonally, and the sprawling outlines run off in great slanting
waves of optic horror” (1071). The way in which the narrator uses syntax to put
many different adjectives together portrays the confusion and disharmony of the
wallpaper. The narrator also writes, “It makes me tired to follow it” (1071).
The narrator’s overall exhaustion matches not only the readers’ exhaustion from
trying to decode her way of describing the wallpaper, but also her own
frustration that she has not been able to fully figure out the wallpaper.
Monday, September 8, 2014
Irony
For our group, we were assigned Chapter 26 of How to Read Literature like a Professor, "Is he serious? And other Ironies". In this chapter, Foster talks about how when irony is being used in literature, the meaning of something always deflects from what is expected by readers. He writes about how a sign in a certain piece of literature can have a predetermined meaning by readers, but with irony the way the author employs the sign becomes the opposite of what the readers expected. In addition, Foster writes about the idea of "dual awareness" which is the dislocation between readers' expectations and the reality (259). Finally, Foster concludes with how the use of irony in literature trumps everything else.
In Their Eyes Were Watching God, Zora Neale Hurston uses irony with her overall message. Hurston uses irony to prove how love does not mean just one specific thing for everyone, and an individual cannot have one expectation for what love should be. She proves this through the contrasting marriages Janie has throughout the novel. Janie's three marriages not only contrast with one another, but also with the expectation Janie once had about love when she was a child daydreaming under the pear tree. Irony contributes to Hurston's purpose of the expectations for love and marriage an individual has against the reality that an individual cannot expect that love means just one thing for everyone.
In Their Eyes Were Watching God, Zora Neale Hurston uses irony with her overall message. Hurston uses irony to prove how love does not mean just one specific thing for everyone, and an individual cannot have one expectation for what love should be. She proves this through the contrasting marriages Janie has throughout the novel. Janie's three marriages not only contrast with one another, but also with the expectation Janie once had about love when she was a child daydreaming under the pear tree. Irony contributes to Hurston's purpose of the expectations for love and marriage an individual has against the reality that an individual cannot expect that love means just one thing for everyone.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
