Thursday, February 12, 2015

"To be or not to be" Soliloquy Analysis


In William Shakespeare’s play Hamlet, the character Hamlet has a soliloquy in which he questions the value of keeping his life when he has so many problems. Hamlet’s inability to make a decision regarding his life emphasizes how an individual’s conscience ultimately influences the decisions that they make. To begin with, Hamlet starts his soliloquy he states, “To die, to sleep…and by a sleep to say we end the heartache and the thousand natural shocks that flesh is heir to” (Shakespeare III.i.68-71). The hope in Hamlet’s tone to potentially end heartache and his problems for once and for all suggest that he is content with ending his life. However, his indecisiveness despite the relief he would feel represents how he is not in control of choosing for himself whether he should live or die because something else is making the decision for him. Hamlet later contradicts himself when he says, “The dread of something after death…makes us rather bear those ills we have” (III.i.86-89). This change in Hamlet from wanting death to fearing it highlights his inability to remain content with his decision and his paranoia of making the wrong choice. By Hamlet not being able to feel confident in one decision, it is revealed that he will not be the one that makes the decision at all. His conscience will have to take over for Hamlet since he is incapable. This is seen when Hamlet later declares, “Thus conscience does make cowards (of us all)” (III.i.91). This statement proves that Hamlet is able to recognize that his conscience will determine his choice. While Hamlet recognizes the ability of his conscience, he is powerless in controlling it. This demonstrates that even though Hamlet spent the entire soliloquy debating, “to be or not to be”, it is his conscience that will make the choice in the end (Shakespeare III.i. 64). Ultimately, Hamlet is faced with an extremely difficult decision that he will never make. Hamlet is weak compared to the power of his conscience, and because it is his conscience that controls his actions, Hamlet will never truly make choices on his own.