Monday, October 27, 2014

Criticisms

George M. Spangler’s criticism of the ending of The Awakening contemplates how the ending of the novel portrays a shift in characterization for Edna. He writes, “Edna suddenly collapses, and what the reader gets in the way of an explanation does not follow from what he has witnessed before”. I completely agree with his criticism because Edna’s character at the end of the novel is completely different from the majority of the novel and the ending is almost contradictory to Chopin’s initial message.

            To begin with, Spangler writes, “throughout the novel the most striking feature of Edna’s character has been her strength of will, her ruthless determination to go her own way”. However, at the end of the novel Edna is extremely weak and the narrator exclaims, ‘but it was too late; the shore was far behind her, and her strength was gone” (157). Edna’s lack of wanting to fight for her own life at the hands of Robert’s rejection proves how different of a character she is at the end of the novel. The independence and strength she found in herself over the course of the novel is completely deteriorated. The abrupt change in her character is unsatisfactory for the ending because the entire novel was building up her own power only for it to be a complete failure in the end, contrary to the expectations of the reader. In addition, the ending of the novel seems to contradict Chopin’s message. Spangler writes, “ Chopin provided a conclusion for a novel other than the one she wrote, a conclusion for a novel much more conventional and much less interesting than The Awakening”. In the conclusion Edna is compared to, “a bird with a broken wing” after being the liberated bird no longer concerned with societal expectations about marriage or love (156). This abrupt shift makes the ending extremely confusing because as a reader I expected Edna to develop her own place in society instead of remaining oppressed in her marriage. However, Edna ultimately succumbs to the oppression and kills herself instead of continuing to fight despite the influence of society. Overall, the ending of The Awakening is completely unsatisfactory because the abrupt change of Edna’s character goes against everything Chopin was writing about for the majority of the novel.

No comments:

Post a Comment